MCMINN COUNTY, TN — DNA advances have given a name to human remains found in McMinn County in 1991, ending more than three decades of uncertainty for investigators and the man’s family. The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation said Thursday that the partial skeletal remains belong to Forest Wayne Loudermilk, a white man from North Carolina.
Authorities now hope the identification will lead to answers about how he died and how he came to be in East Tennessee. McMinn County detectives are asking anyone with information, especially details about who Loudermilk may have been with before his death, to contact investigators.
Partial skull discovered in a yard in 1991
The remains were found on April 10, 1991, in a residential area of McMinn County. According to Othram Inc., the private Texas laboratory that later worked on the case, the discovery was a portion of a human skull, specifically a partial cranium, found in a yard.
Forensic anthropologists at the time believed the remains belonged to a Black man between the ages of 31 and 50. McMinn County Sheriff’s Office investigators and the University of Tennessee Forensic Anthropology Center tried to identify the person using the technology available then, but those efforts did not succeed.
With no other leads, the remains were classified as John Doe and stayed unidentified for more than 30 years.
A 2015 DNA profile still left investigators without a name
The TBI said the case took a new turn in 2015, when the University of Tennessee Forensic Anthropology Center submitted a sample to the University of Texas Center for Human Identification. There, specialists developed a DNA profile that was entered into the Combined DNA Index System and the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System.
Those databases gave investigators a new avenue for searching, but the effort did not produce an identification. For years, the profile sat without a confirmed match as the case remained unresolved.
That changed only after a newer round of testing was possible through the state’s unidentified human remains initiative.
Othram testing led investigators to relatives and a match
In May 2025, TBI agents helped the sheriff’s office and the University of Tennessee Forensic Anthropology Center submit another sample to Othram through the agency’s Unidentified Human Remains DNA Initiative. Othram uses forensic genetic genealogy testing, a method that can produce DNA profiles even from very old remains.
According to the TBI, Othram scientists identified possible relatives of the unknown man. Investigators then contacted one of those relatives and obtained a family DNA sample for comparison.
That comparison confirmed the remains belonged to Loudermilk. The identification closed a case that had remained open since the early 1990s.
Family members last heard from Loudermilk around 1980
Investigators said Loudermilk was last seen by family members around 1980, when he would have been about 49 or 50 years old. That gap means he may have been missing for roughly a decade before the remains were discovered in McMinn County.
Even with the identification complete, investigators still do not know what happened to him. The TBI and McMinn County detectives are now focused on reconstructing his final days and understanding the circumstances that led to his death.
Officials say any detail, no matter how small, could help move the case forward.
Detectives seek public help and a photograph of Loudermilk
McMinn County detectives are asking the public to come forward with information about Loudermilk, especially anything related to who he may have been with before he died. People with tips are asked to call the McMinn County Sheriff’s Office at 423-745-5620, extension 1928.
Investigators are also looking for a photograph of Loudermilk, but an extensive search has not turned one up. Sheriff Joe Guy said the case reflects a strong working relationship with TBI divisions and urged anyone with information to help the family find more peace and closure.
The identification gives Loudermilk’s relatives a name after decades of questions, but the cause and manner of his death remain unknown.
